Management Accounting and Financial Accounting: 22 Best Differences

Management Accounting and Financial Accounting: 22 Best Differences

Management accounting and financial accounting, together with cost accounting, are the three main branches of accounting. Accounting is often described as the language of business, but it is not one single subject. With the growth of trade and industry, it has divided into separate branches, each serving a different purpose.

All three draw on the same basic records of the business, which is why students often find it hard to tell them apart. The real difference lies in the purpose for which information is prepared, the people who use it and the way it is presented. For more solved B.Com questions, visit GNDU Papers.

Question: How is Management Accounting different from Financial Accounting and Cost Accounting?

Financial accounting is concerned with recording what has already happened and reporting the results. Cost accounting is concerned with finding and controlling the cost of products and activities. Management accounting uses the information from both to help managers plan ahead and take decisions.

To understand the difference clearly, it is first necessary to know the meaning of each branch.

Meaning of Financial Accounting

Financial accounting is the process of recording, classifying and summarising business transactions in terms of money. At the end of the accounting year, it prepares the Profit and Loss Account and the Balance Sheet.

These statements show the profit or loss earned during the year and the financial position of the business on the last day of the year. The main users of these statements are outsiders such as shareholders, creditors, banks, investors and the government. You can also read about the limitations of financial accounting.

Meaning of Cost Accounting

Cost accounting is the branch that deals with collecting, classifying and analysing costs. It finds out the cost of each product, job, process or service, and shows how much is spent on material, labour and overheads.

It helps the business fix selling prices, control wastage and keep costs within limits. Cost accounting is used mainly inside the business, especially in manufacturing concerns. A general overview of cost accounting is available on Wikipedia.

Meaning of Management Accounting

Management accounting is the presentation of accounting information in a form that helps management in planning, controlling and decision-making. It does not maintain a separate set of books.

Instead, it takes figures from financial accounting and cost accounting, adds other relevant information, analyses it and presents it to managers in the form of reports, budgets and statements. Its features and areas are explained in detail in our answer on the nature and scope of management accounting.

Difference Between Management Accounting and Financial Accounting

1. Purpose

Management Accounting: It is meant to help managers in planning, controlling and taking decisions.

Financial Accounting: It is meant to record transactions and to show the profit or loss and financial position of the business.

2. Users

Management Accounting: The information is used by managers working inside the business.

Financial Accounting: The information is used mainly by outsiders such as shareholders, creditors, banks and tax authorities.

3. Period Covered

Management Accounting: It is concerned mostly with the future. Past data is used only as a base for forecasts and budgets.

Financial Accounting: It is concerned with the past, since it records transactions that have already taken place.

4. Legal Position

Management Accounting: It is optional, and no law requires a business to adopt it.

Financial Accounting: It is compulsory for companies and many other concerns under the Companies Act and tax laws.

5. Rules and Formats

Management Accounting: It has no fixed rules or formats, and reports are prepared in whatever form management finds useful.

Financial Accounting: It must follow generally accepted accounting principles, accounting standards and legal formats.

6. Type of Data

Management Accounting: It uses money figures as well as non-money data, such as units produced, labour hours and market share.

Financial Accounting: It records only those transactions that can be measured in money.

7. Degree of Accuracy

Management Accounting: Approximate figures and estimates are acceptable, because managers often need information quickly.

Financial Accounting: Figures must be exact and verifiable, since the accounts are checked by auditors.

8. Frequency of Reports

Management Accounting: Reports are prepared whenever needed, which may be daily, weekly or monthly.

Financial Accounting: Statements are prepared at fixed intervals, usually at the end of the year.

9. Unit of Reporting

Management Accounting: It reports on parts of the business, such as departments, products, branches or projects.

Financial Accounting: It reports on the business as a whole.

10. Audit

Management Accounting: Its reports are not subject to external audit.

Financial Accounting: Its accounts must be audited, particularly in the case of companies.

11. Publication

Management Accounting: Reports are confidential and remain within the organisation.

Financial Accounting: Final accounts are published or made available to the public and other outsiders.

12. Nature

Management Accounting: It is partly an art and partly a science, because it depends on judgement and estimates.

Financial Accounting: It is more of a science, because it follows settled rules and procedures.

Difference Between Management Accounting and Cost Accounting

1. Objective

Management Accounting: Its objective is to provide information for all kinds of managerial decisions.

Cost Accounting: Its objective is to ascertain and control the cost of products and activities.

2. Scope

Management Accounting: Its scope is wide and includes financial accounting, cost accounting, budgeting, tax planning, financial analysis and reporting.

Cost Accounting: Its scope is limited to matters relating to cost.

3. Nature of Information

Management Accounting: It uses cost data along with financial data, statistical data and general economic information.

Cost Accounting: It deals mainly with data relating to material, labour and overheads.

4. Time Orientation

Management Accounting: It is mainly concerned with future planning and policy.

Cost Accounting: It deals with both historical costs and predetermined or standard costs.

5. Development

Management Accounting: It developed later, growing out of financial accounting and cost accounting.

Cost Accounting: It developed earlier, mainly to meet the needs of manufacturing industries.

6. Dependence

Management Accounting: It depends on cost accounting and financial accounting for its basic data and cannot function without them.

Cost Accounting: It can be installed and operated independently of a management accounting system.

7. Techniques

Management Accounting: It uses budgetary control, ratio analysis, fund flow and cash flow statements, marginal costing and other decision-making tools.

Cost Accounting: It uses job costing, process costing, standard costing and variance analysis.

8. Legal Requirement

Management Accounting: It is never compulsory under any law.

Cost Accounting: In India, maintenance of cost records is required for certain industries under the Companies (Cost Records and Audit) Rules. The profession of cost accountancy in India is regulated by the Institute of Cost Accountants of India.

9. Audit

Management Accounting: There is no provision for audit of management accounting reports.

Cost Accounting: Cost audit is compulsory for some notified industries.

10. Users within the Organisation

Management Accounting: Its reports serve top, middle and lower levels of management.

Cost Accounting: Its reports are used mainly by production managers and cost controllers.

Relationship Among the Three Branches

Although the three branches differ in purpose and approach, they are closely connected and depend on one another.

Financial accounting provides the foundation. It records every transaction of the business, and without reliable financial records, neither cost accounting nor management accounting can produce correct results.

Cost accounting builds on this foundation. It breaks down expenses in detail and shows the cost of each product, process and department. This detailed cost information is very useful for pricing and cost control.

Management accounting makes use of both. It takes the records of financial accounting and the cost data of cost accounting, combines them with other relevant information, and presents the result in a form that helps management plan and act.

For this reason, management accounting is not a replacement for the other two branches. It adds value to the information they provide and makes it more useful for decision-making.

Conclusion

Financial accounting, cost accounting and management accounting are three related branches of accounting, but each has a distinct role. Financial accounting records past transactions and reports the results to outsiders in a fixed legal format.

Cost accounting ascertains and controls the cost of products and activities, mainly for internal use. Management accounting goes further than both. It uses their information, looks towards the future and supports managers in planning, controlling and taking decisions.

Management accounting is wider in scope, flexible in form and meant only for internal use. It is not compulsory under law and its reports are not audited. Financial accounting and cost accounting supply the raw material, while management accounting converts that material into information on which sound business decisions can be based. For more important questions and previous year papers of B.Com, check the GNDU Papers homepage.